In Thursday’s hearing, Judge Kessler talked about her concerns about The MN Depository. In her 2006 verdict, Judge Kessler ordered the MN and Guildford Depositories to be maintained until 2021, but she said she was concerned, partly because the MN judge [Ramsey County Judge Guthman] who is currently in charge of the depository is concerned. […]
Judge Kessler’s Order # 7 (below) offers a succinct precise of the issues addressed during Monday’s Status Hearing.
Now that the Supreme Court has upheld Kessler’s judgment, all that’s left in the tobacco case is to determine the specifics of Kessler’s Order #1015 “Final Judgment and Remedial Order” (Aug. 17, 2006 ). Not so simple; this […]
On September 28, 2009, the tobacco Defendants asked the US Court of Appeals, DC Circuit to stay issuance of its mandate, pending Defendants’ filing and disposition of petitions for writs of certiorari to the Supreme Court.
The Court’s mandate would require Defendants to:
remove “light” and “low tar” descriptors from the packages and brand names of […]
THIS IS IT!
The Ronald M. Davis Tobacco Deposition & Trial Testimony Archive at Tobacco Documents Online (TDO) has the collected transcripts and depositions of UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. PHILIP MORRIS INC–complete with abstracts(!)
MANY THANKS to the staff of Michigan Public Health Institute’s Center for Tobacco Use Prevention & Research.
FEAST!
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA […]
I’ll have to post a precis of the argument in chunks. For now, I’ll try to quickly recap some of the industry’s position, as expressed by Michael Carvin in the first 1/2 hour of argument. This is by no means a complete recap of the issues. Yet, the wire services just don’t have room for […]
The Supreme Court Justices seemed most concerned about Congress’ intent in the 1965 Federal Cigarette Labeling and Advertising Act. Did Congress mean to preempt all law and lawsuits having anything to do with advertising and smoking and health?
Altria’s lawyer, Ted Olson, had to overcome some Justices’ cavils about the sweeping nature of the Labeling Act’s […]
The Justices today were tough on Altria lawyer Ted Olson, tougher on Good lawyer David C. Frederick–and toughest of all on DOJ lawyer Douglas Hallward-Driemeier, Assistant to the Solicitor General.
Justice Alito told Hallward-Driemeier that he found the government’s position “incomprehensible” if the FTC tar/nicotine figures are meaningless.
“You created this whole problem,” Justice Alito told him. […]
§ 1331. Congressional declaration of policy and purpose
It is the policy of Congress, and the purpose of this chapter, to establish a comprehensive Federal program to deal with cigarette labeling and advertising with respect to any relationship between smoking and health . . .
No statement relating to smoking and health, other than the statement required […]
On Oct. 31, 2006, a 3-judge DC Court of Appeals panel granted the Defense’s motion to stay Judge Kessler’s Judgement and Order.
It’s odd, to me, that no news source pointed out that the panel included, once again, Judges Sentelle and Tatel. Judge Sentelle, once again, found for tobacco. Judge Tatel, once again, dissented from […]
On October 30, 2006,the parties submitted their praecipes on the practicality and effectiveness of each others’ correctives, as required by Judge Kessler in her Order #1025 (Kessler Order #1025 on Correctives, Oct. 19, 2006.) She had found the parties’ previous filings had raised new issues, and some suggestions might require too “hands on” an approach […]